Sole proprietor or company: the tax on the same profit
Enter a year’s business profit to see what a sole proprietor pays in tax next to what the same business pays through a company in 2026-27. The company side counts company tax, dividends tax and the income tax on any salary it pays you.
Your comparison
As a sole proprietor you pay less tax by
R32,465
| Figure | Sole proprietor | Company27 percent company rate |
|---|---|---|
| Profit before any salary to you | R600,000 | R600,000 |
| Salary the company pays youA sole proprietor cannot deduct pay to themselves. | None | R300,000 |
| Your own income taxOn the whole profit, or on the salary alone through a company. | R132,907 | R40,572 |
| Company tax | R0 | R81,000 |
| Dividend paid to youOnly a company pays dividends. | None | R219,000 |
| Dividends tax20 percent, taken off by the company. | R0 | R43,800 |
| Total tax | R132,907lower total | R165,372 |
| Share of the profit paid in tax | 22.2 percent | 27.6 percent |
| What you keep this year | R467,093 | R434,628 |
How each column was worked out
Sole proprietor
- Profit taxed as your own incomeA sole proprietor and the business are the same taxpayer, which puts the whole profit on the individual table.
- R600,000
- Income tax after your rebatesWorked as R125,599 plus 36 percent of the amount above R530,200, with the rebates for your age taken off.
- R132,907
- What you keepThe profit less the income tax.
- R467,093
- Total tax as a sole proprietor
- R132,907
Company
- Salary the company pays youThe company can deduct it because the tool assumes it is a fair rate for work you actually do.
- R300,000
- Your income tax on the salaryWorked on the individual table with the rebates for your age taken off. Dividends from a South African company are exempt from income tax and do not add to this figure.
- R40,572
- Company taxable incomeThe profit less the salary.
- R300,000
- Company taxThe standard company rate of 27 percent of taxable income.
- R81,000
- Profit after company taxWhat the company has left to pay out or keep.
- R219,000
- Dividend paid to you100 percent of the profit after company tax.
- R219,000
- Dividends tax20 percent of the dividend, taken off by the company before you are paid and paid to SARS by the end of the next month.
- R43,800
- Profit left in the companyBelongs to the company until it is paid out.
- R0
- Tax paid this yearYour tax on the salary, plus company tax, plus dividends tax on this year’s dividend.
- R165,372
- What you keep this yearThe salary and the dividend, each less its tax.
- R434,628
- Dividends tax still to come on the profit left in the companyAt today’s 20 percent, due only when that profit is paid out.
- R0
- Total tax through a company once all the profit is paid out
- R165,372
Rates verified against SARS on 27 September 2026, for the 2027 year of assessment. Treat these figures as an estimate to review with a registered tax practitioner before you act on them, because they assume the business is your only income and leave out the costs of running a company.
The comparison is worked out in your browser as you type, and the tool asks for no sign-up or email address. The site runs anonymised analytics and an anonymised recording of each visit (a session replay), which hides the numbers you type here, and you can switch both off from the footer.
The figures come from the SARS pages on company and small business corporation tax rates, tax rates for individuals and dividends tax, and from the SARS Budget 2026 tax guide.
What this comparison leaves out
The totals cover income tax, company tax and dividends tax on one year’s profit in the 2026-27 tax year, with the company’s financial year assumed to end on 28 February 2027, the same day your own tax year ends. The list below covers what those totals leave out.
- The tool assumes the business is your only income. A salary from a job, rent, interest or a pension would push the sole proprietor’s profit, and any salary the company pays you, into higher tax brackets, while company tax and dividends tax would stay the same. Retirement fund contributions, medical scheme credits and other personal deductions are left out of both columns.
- It models one owner who is a South African resident and owns the whole business, or every share in the company. Partnerships, several shareholders, and shares held by a trust, another company or a non-resident follow other rules.
- A company costs more to run. It files an annual return with the CIPC (the companies registry) and pays accounting fees, and the Companies Act requires some companies to have an independent review or audit. Paying yourself a salary also means running a payroll. The income tax on your salary is already in the totals, and the PAYE calculator works out what comes off each month. UIF may apply to an owner-director, at 1 percent from the company and 1 percent from you on pay up to R17,712 a month. The skills development levy of 1 percent of payroll applies once total salaries are expected to go above R500,000 over the next 12 months.
- Both routes pay provisional tax, which is income tax paid in advance in two payments during the year. The dates and any interest are outside this comparison, and our provisional tax calculator does those sums.
- The tool compares a profit only, so a loss this year, or an unused loss from a past year (what SARS calls an assessed loss), is outside it. It also starts both routes from the same profit, although a small business corporation can write off some equipment faster than a sole proprietor can, which could lower the company’s taxable profit in a year the business buys equipment.
- If your own professional work, such as consulting, IT, accounting, law or engineering, together with any investment income, makes up more than 20 percent of the company’s income, the company fails the small business corporation tests unless it has three or more full-time staff in that work who are not connected to you. It may also be a personal service provider, a company whose owner works for its clients much as an employee would, which is taxed at 27 percent with few deductions. The tool cannot model either rule.
- Loans from the company to you, fringe benefits such as a company car, and dividends paid in assets carry their own tax rules and are left out. So is capital gains tax on a later sale of the business or its shares, where an individual pays at most 18 percent of the gain and a company at most 21.6 percent, with dividends tax to follow when the company pays that money out.
- Turnover tax is a third option for very small businesses, charged on total sales in place of income tax. This tool does not work it out, and SARS explains who qualifies on its turnover tax page. VAT works the same way under both structures, so it plays no part in the comparison.
Which suits which business
On tax alone, the answer changes with the size of the profit and with how much of it you take as a salary. A salary from the company is taxed like a sole proprietor’s profit, with the same rebate and brackets, so a salary equal to the whole profit leaves both routes paying the same tax. Any saving through a company comes from the part paid out as a dividend, when company tax and dividends tax on it add up to less than your personal rate on the same money. For a small business corporation that can start once the profit goes past R245,100, the top of the lowest personal bracket, if your salary is set at that amount and the remaining profit is paid out as a dividend.
A standard company is different, because company tax and dividends tax together take 41.6 percent of every rand it pays out as a dividend. That only beats your personal rate once the profit is in the top personal bracket, above R1,878,600, which is why passing the small business corporation tests often decides it.
The two structures also work differently in law. A company is a separate legal person, with contracts, bank accounts and assets in its own name, and you can sell part of the business by selling some of its shares. It takes more work to run, with separate books, the yearly costs above and its own SARS filing dates, which our guide to the company tax compliance calendar sets out. A sole proprietor has the least paperwork, but in law the owner and the business are the same person, so the owner is personally responsible for the business’s debts.
Money inside a company belongs to the company, and you take it out as a salary, taxed as your income, or as a dividend, which carries dividends tax. A loan from the company to you has tax rules of its own. Which of these matters most depends on the business and the person running it, so talk it through with a registered tax practitioner before you change the structure.
Questions about sole proprietor and company tax
- Is it cheaper to trade as a sole proprietor or through a company in South Africa?
- It depends on the size of the profit and on how you take money out of the company. On the 2026-27 figures, an owner aged 40 with a R300,000 profit pays R40,572 in tax as a sole proprietor. A small business corporation that pays the whole profit out as a dividend costs R71,256, while a R245,100 salary with the balance as a dividend brings its total down to R37,278, a little less than the sole proprietor pays. At a R1,500,000 profit, the same kind of company pays R434,483 in total with a R600,000 salary and the rest as a dividend, against R493,293 for a sole proprietor.
- How much is dividends tax in South Africa?
- Dividends tax is 20 percent of the dividend. The company takes it off before it pays you and pays it to SARS by the last day of the following month. The dividend is then free of income tax in your hands, and because your rebate only reduces income tax, even a small dividend carries the full 20 percent.
- What is a small business corporation?
- It is a company that passes the tests in section 12E of the Income Tax Act, which lets SARS tax it on a lower table. For company years ending between 1 April 2026 and 31 March 2027 the table charges nothing on the first R99,000 of taxable income, then 7 percent on the slice up to R365,000, 21 percent on the slice up to R550,000 and 27 percent on everything above R550,000. There are five tests. The company must be a private company, close corporation, co-operative or personal liability company owned only by individuals, and none of those owners can hold shares in other companies apart from a few kinds SARS allows. Its gross income, meaning its earnings before expenses, must be R20,000,000 or less, and investment income and income from personal services together can make up no more than 20 percent of its income and capital gains. The last test is that the company cannot be a personal service provider.
- How is a salary taxed compared with a dividend from my own company?
- A salary comes off the company’s profit before company tax and you pay income tax on it at your personal rates, while a dividend comes out of profit that has already carried company tax and has 20 percent dividends tax taken off it as well. For an owner aged 40 with no other income, a salary of R99,000 or less is free of income tax. The company can deduct the salary only if it is real pay for work the owner does, at the kind of rate it would pay someone else. Try a few salaries in the calculator to see how the total moves.
- Does keeping profit in the company save tax?
- It moves part of the tax to a later year. Company tax is due on the profit either way, and the dividends tax on the part kept in the company falls due when that money is paid out, at whatever the rate is then. A R1,500,000 profit in a company taxed at 27 percent that pays out half carries R514,500 in tax this year and another R109,500 later, which is why the calculator compares the two routes on the total once everything is paid out. You can try a smaller payout under “Keeping some profit in the company” in the calculator.
The filings that follow a move to a company
When a client moves their business into a company, the practice looks after two taxpayers where there used to be one. The company files an income tax return (the ITR14) every year and makes two provisional tax payments, and once it pays a salary it also submits a monthly EMP201 payroll return, with a different due date for each. For a practice with many business clients, C-Suite Commercial keeps those dates on one calendar for every company and chases the documents each filing needs, and the pilot week lets you see that calendar on a client of yours before you decide anything.